The Ukrainian Invasion of Russia: Why It Will Fail

To understand the Ukrainian invasion of Russia, we must understand certain facts about Russia. First, Russia is huge compared to Ukraine, 28.5 times larger, and has the largest land area of any country in the world. The Russians can afford to have the Ukrainians conquer a lot of Russian territory, while evacuating its civilians and pretending to fight. The Ukrainians will be stretched too thin after a while and their supply lines will be too long. It won't affect what is happening on the battlefield within Ukraine.

Second, Russia has a unique military history. They are experienced in giving up ground to buy time until fall and winter weather, with its rain, cold, snow, and ice makes roads impassible and invading armies ineffective. That is how Napoleon's army was defeated when it invaded Russia, and also what helped defeat Nazi Germany, aside from Hitler's insistence on overruling his generals.

Third, the Russian population is 3.5 times larger than Ukraine's population. Ukraine is running out of soldiers. The Russians can keep on throwing troops at Ukrainian soldiers to wear them out, and sustain high losses while doing so.

For the Ukrainian invasion, Russia only needs to pretend to fight Ukraine, and wait for the muddy season of the year to occur, which will occur in the fall.

However, Ukraine's seizure of territory has embarrassed Putin to the extent that he has pulled some troops from Ukraine to fight the invasion and quell public unease. He has obtained 10,000 troops from North Korea to help fight the war with Ukraine because the numbers of Russian troops are limited. He dares not call up a full scale conscription because there would be a backlash within Russia. Being conscripted to fight in a war is seldom popular anywhere, including Russia.

In the long run, however, Russia should be able to push out the Ukrainian invasion. Putin does not like to lose, or give up on any prominent position he has taken, regardless of the cost to his nation.

We do know that the Russian banking sector raised interest rates to 21% near the end of October, 2024, and inflation was projected to average 8.8% for the year. And there have been reports that the Russian railway system is near breakdown because of a lack of ball bearings embargoed by the West.

Both the stress on Russia's economy and Ukraine's seizure of Russian territory are putting pressure on Putin to stop his ill-advised war. However, unless the invasion causes so much additional disruption that his generals seriously question the war, he may be able to keep pecking away at Ukraine for a long time.

Ukraine, meanwhile is suffering greatly from the war. Russia is gradually learning from its mistakes on the battlefield and getting better at using drones to kill Ukrainian troops and civilians. The war has degenerated into the use of missiles and drones, with those of Russia destroying Ukrainian infrastructure, including the energy grid before winter, and terrorizing civilians.

Ukraine's economic and manpower means are limited. When the United States drops its commitment to assist Ukraine, president Zelenskyy will have to come to the realization that he must concede some territory in the short term for peace. The European Union, shamefully, is still too weak militarily to provide sufficient weapons and ammunition to Ukraine.


Ukrainian demonstration by Karabo Spain, Pixabay

14 November 2024
© 2023-2024 by Topically.org